Much Ado About Matcha:
Appreciating the Taste of
Powdered Green Tea
by Lauren W. Deutsch,
Sochi
(Originally published in Kyoto Journal, #71 2009)
You’ve
seen her about town, demurely coifed and impeccably dressed in a shimmering
kimono of a refreshing hue of green upon which seasonal grasses and a single
flower bud blossom onto her obi. Perhaps you know her by her stage names,
poetic impressions conjured up by her esteemed patrons, among which she counts
many of Kyoto’s elite – the current grand masters of traditional hospitality and
those for over 16 generations before. She is invited to be present in complex
rituals that honor the most noble of Japan’s warriors. Her renown is jealously
guarded as one would a fine songbird of rare voice. A sweet confidence marks
her beguiling gestures. Even after one chance meeting, one is left with an
impression that is deep and full.
She
is, of course, “Matcha-sama” – Japan’s beloved emerald empress of high
traditional culture, the national muse whose substance is the finest powdered
camellia sinensis. Even in Kyoto, the undisputed center of the Japanese tea
world, wherever she goes, she is in a class by herself. Her reputation is
impeccable, albeit “Old School”; she is outnumbered by the likes of upstart
“Punky Poky Bobacha-chan” and “Frappalattechino-chan”.
If
you think that chanoyu, the Japanese tea ritual, is primarily about enjoying
the flavor of matcha ... I have a bridge to sell you! Let’s call it the
ultimate Japanese “urban myth”. Making matcha – mixing of hot water and a tiny
bit of carefully selected, hand-picked young green tea leaves in powdered form
– is merely the premise for a refined social gathering. Unlike oenophiles who
can wax poetic about the taste factors of their beloved wine, chado
practitioners, folks who make the Way of Tea their Way of Life, are hard
pressed to discuss the distinct taste characteristics of dozens of comparably
prepared teas from each other of the same grade.
So
what’s the fuss about a tea ceremony? Why are there so many different products
marketed if there’s no discrimination? Why has making and sharing a bowl of
matcha been one of the prime markers of Japanese culture for over half a
millennium? Does one have to study 10+ years and make thousands of bowls of tea
to get a handle on the taste? Maybe. Maybe not.
The
Taste of a Bowl of Emptiness
Tea is not a game and not an art.
One taste of tea refreshes and purifies
And gives enlightenment to the universal law.
–Murata Shukô (1423-1502)
Tea
– enjoyed in powdered leaf form – was imported to Japan from China along with
Rinzai Zen Buddhism by Yosai in about 1192 A.D. and was first planted at
Kozanji Temple in Toga-no-o in the northwestern region of Kyoto. Other temples
began to plant tea for their own consumption, as did the imperial palace in the
early 9th century.1
Tea
was popular among the monastic set for its medicinal effect; its high level of
caffeine kept them clearheaded and awake during long periods of sitting zazen
meditation. In China, back then, tea was relegated to the “bitter” category of
the Five Element Theory2 of Traditional Oriental Medicine, thus good for the
heart. (Only recently has the West adopted pungency as the official fifth taste
sensation. Umami as its known is a signature Japanese flavor projecting a
broth-like, pungent “heartiness” sensation associated with fermented and aged
foods. More about umani to come!)
Priest
Myô-ei Shonin went to the trouble to delineate “10 Virtues of Tea”3, but
none were about the taste.
Tea ...
Has the blessing of all the Deities.
Promotes filial piety.
Drives away the Devil.
Banishes drowsiness.
Keeps the Five Viscera in harmony.
Wards off disease.
Strengthens friendships.
Disciplines body and mind.
Destroys the passions.
Gives a peaceful death.
Rather
than also bring back methods of cultivation of the plant, they told us how to
cultivate the mind: there is ... no ... discrimination ... no ... nose, tongue,
body ... smell, taste ...” in emptiness. It may be a good recipe for
enlightenment, but not for gourmands. Murata Shukô (1423 – 1502), renowned among
his peers for dozing on the zafu meditation cushion, one day finally woke up,
jumped up, declaring, “Chazen ichi mi" – “Tea and Zen are the same taste!”
and exchanged the dark, smoky zendo for a life of tea drinking in the secular
world. He got points from his iconoclastic teacher priest Ikkyu, also a
proponent of chanoyu.
Tea,
the medicine and the Chinese-inspired ways to prepare it ritually, began to
make its way out of the monastery into the Buddhist-influenced secular world of
warlords and merchants, particularly through Takeno Jô (1502-1555), and his
famed student Sen no Rikyu (1522-1591). Shoguns from the late Ashigakas through
the Toyotomis, especially the egomaniacal Shogun Hideyoshi Toyotomi, became
patrons of chajin tea practitioners and the latter became formal members of
their courtly retinue. Tea utensils trumped the plant in value, and these
objects often were coveted more highly than real estate as spoils of war
victories. There are tomes written about the crafting and collecting of Chinese
tea caddies and Korean tea bowls, as well as the rise of domestic craft
production in ceramics, metal, fine fabric, lacquered wood, bamboo and other
materials for the performance of the ritual.
Elaborate
tea gatherings were refined compositions of hospitality that demonstrated the
host’s skills in incorporating fleeting seasonal elements into ichi go ichi e
... “One time. One meeting.” The practice became a living embodiment of the
cultivation of wa, kei, sei and jaku, harmony, respect, purity and tranquility.
Everything about tea – the architecture, landscaping, culinary histories and
more – has been fair game for meticulously-researched connoisseurship ...
except the taste of tea itself. While never completely disassociated from
temple life, the preparation of chanoyu morphed into chado as a secular
vocation, now 16 generations long, of folks with impeccable taste, and hundreds
of thousands of their followers.
The
Earth’s Gifts: A Matcha Primer
Like
wine and perhaps even more like beer, creating fine matcha has everything to do
with rootstock / plant, the soil and its geographic placement, weather,
techniques of growing, manufacturing and storage, all of which will impact its
taste. Here are some hints about such variables as encountered in tea production
today.
§ Location. Location. Location.
Fine
matcha is usually associated with the town of Uji in the southern end of Kyoto,
near Byodo-in Temple. With a deep bow to the history and tea commerce, today
it’s a lovely tourist town full of little tea shops situated along the river
that shares its name, once considered a source of potable water excellent for
chanoyu. Outside the “downtown” are the tea plantations and processing and
storage facilities. Matcha that bears the distinction as “Ujicha” may have been
grown in Kyoto, Nara, Shiga and Mie Prefectures and “finished” in Uji. Ujicha
is most associated with the more conservative, formal tea schools that were
patronized by the elite chado families and Shogunate, such as Ippodo (founded
in 1717), Kanbayashi (1500), Koyamaen (late 1600s), and relative newcomer
Ryuonen (1875).
On
the other hand, Aiya Saijoen, founded in 1888, obtains its tea leaves from 850
year-old family farms in Nishiio,Aichi Prefecture. These tea plants enjoy a
terrior benefiting from being near three rivers and the soil is
characteristically less “heavy” with minerals than that of Uji. Yet, to all but
the most experienced tea tasters, terror influence is imperceptible, unlike,
for example, the impact of limestone in the soil nourishing a fine pinot noir,
for example. While Nishio claims to have hosted the largest tea ceremony4,
Shizuoka Prefecture, which hosts a large international tea exposition5,
boasts being the largest tea-growing region in Japan, having been producing for
over 650 years.
§ Vintage
The
tea growing cycle goes from spring through fall. Unlike wine and fermented teas
which improve with age, and like beer which is best enjoyed fresh, matcha is
usually consumed over a single year’s time. Its taste declines with age and
improper storage and handling.
§ Root Stock and Soil
According
to Atsushi Yasui-san of Hibiki-an6, gokoh, samidori, and komakage varietals of camellia
sinensis are best suited for producing gyokuro, the finest grade of tea from
which the youngest (top) “two flags and a spine” (two leaves and a bud) are
hand-selected to be dried, sorted and finely ground into matcha. Koicha, matcha
prepared in “thick” concentration of powdered leaf to water, is from root stock
of about 200 years of age; usucha, “thinly” prepared matcha, comes from younger
plants. Good drainage is critical as well, so tea plantations tend to be on
slopes.
High
quality gyokuro tea trees need to be fertilized (fish meal, bean meal) about
three times as much as other teas, such as those for sencha. The soil’s
nitrogen content (whether natural or increased through fertilization) impacts
the amount of L-theanine, an amino acid that is source of the “sweetness or its
deliciousness” umami taste. “Perhaps what gives tea its is the way that L-theanine stimulates the taste-buds.”7 Pesticides are hardly ever used, even on
“non-organic” products.
Organic
production is of great current interest. All matcha was originally organically
produced. Today, Japan strictly regulates its production of agricultural
products labeled as such. With modern fertilizers, there can be “super”
matchas, ones especially high in nitrogen in which the taste more “grassy”. The
organic teas are less sweet, according to Shiro Nobunaga, former sales director of Shizuoka tea producer Aiya America, Inc.8 There are ways to challenge nature to produce a
more broadly pleasing product, balancing bitterness and sweetness in the most
pleasing proportions.
§ Weather
The
history of weather – most notably rainfall (about 1,500 mm / year) and high day
and night temperature contract (with high expectancy of mist) – will affect the
quantity of tea available. Nobunaga noted that in 2007 and 2008 the volume was
less due to rainfall issues, but the quality was maintained.
Finished
in Darkness and Hand-Picked
For
the last 20 – 30 days prior to picking, mid April to May – traditionally 88
days after the festivities of setsubun a late-winter holiday, the fields of
gyokuro plants destined for matcha are covered with progressively applied
shades made of reed, rice straw or fiber to a height of about seven feet9,
one layer per week for three to four weeks depending upon weather. According to
Mr. Nobunaga, "When you shade the tencha fields, the leaves try to collect
more sunlight, thus becoming wider, thinner and softer. This is why when you
hand pick these top, young shoots, you get the most resilient green color and
also it becomes the finest in particle size when you grind them with the
granite wheels. The finer the matcha in particle size, more smooth and creamy
the taste and texture (not grainy like the lower grades).”
This
unique growing method forces the plant to produce more chlorophyll as it
strains to absorb whatever light there is. It also reduces the tendency of
L-theanine from turning into catechin, a component of tannin that is connected
with shibui, astringency. Both L-theanine and tannin have calming properties,
yet matcha has the capacity to stimulate. More L-theanine, an antioxidant, more
umami flavor. Modern science has recognized L-theanine to be effective in the
treatment of high blood pressure, cancer, heart disease and other ailments.
(Remember, the Chinese medicinal system relates the taste of “bitter” with the
major organ of the “heart”.)
As
noted, tea for matcha is always picked carefully by hand during May, about 88
days after setsubun, the festival marking winter’s end. Like the grape crush,
the entire field is picked through until all the leaves appropriate for matcha
are picked. There is no second or late harvest. The leaves undergo a variety of
manufacturing processes that steam (arrest oxidation and maintain color, flavor
and aroma), dry (air and heat) and cut them. The leaves are separated from the
stems and veins, with the remaining 10 percent of the plant called tencha.
Finally, it is graded by size through a number of winnowing activities and
allocated to be suitable for koicha or usucha. Tea for matcha is not rolled
like sencha and other infusing teas. Tea for matcha is never rolled, as is
common in the processing of gyokuro.
Tea
“sommeliers”, as Nobunaga-san calls them, are in charge of carefully blending
the tencha plants grown in different types of soil according to “secret
formulas” to create blends that are consistent over time, expertly recognizable
and which are assigned various product names. No one that I spoke with
indicated there being any premium attached to drinking the product of a single
tea plant type, or as in the wine world, where vertical (vintage) comparisons
are much discussed among connoisseurs and the quality plus quantity of which
impact the price.
§ Grinding
The
first grinding occurs in November. Today, as in Rikyu’s time, the tencha is
still ground between two horizontal granite stone mill wheels, the only
contemporary change is that the wheels are turned by machine at a speed (55
rpm) equal to that of human power. It is estimated that it takes an hour of
grinding to produce one ounce of matcha. Not all the tencha is ground at once.
Mr. Nobunaga explains that Aiya stores its tencha in refrigerated facilities
and grinds it throughout the year based upon the market’s demand. In the “old
days”, grinding was done by the tea master prior to serving it.
As
would be expected, even in the best storage, fresh tencha destined for matcha
will decrease in intensity through the course of the year. For this reason, the
chanoyu preparation techniques, especially koicha, will take into account the
intensity of flavor; the temperature of the hot water will be allowed to drop
before being added to matcha in the late spring through early fall when the
strength of the sensitive leaf has diminished. Matcha is usually sifted about
three times to render it as fine powder without clumps just prior to placing it
in a ceremonial container.
The
First Tea Gathering of the Year
In
the most formal of settings, such as those observed by the elite chajin
families, their empty chatsubo ceramic tea jar is delivered to the chashi tea
producer who puts small bags (75 gms) of appropriate variety of koicha (finest
grade for the formal, thick presentation) into the jar and fills the rest with
tsumi-cha (tea leaves) for the informal, usucha (thin preparation). He puts on
the lid, seals it and marks it with his hanko stamp. The chatsubo is placed
back into its box to which is affixed a list of its contents by the chamei
poetic name of the tea. The jar is returned with a gift of thanks to the owner
and arrives with much anticipation and fanfare.
The
arrival and opening of the chatsubo is the commencement of first private chaji
tea gathering of the new year, coinciding with the opening of the tea room’s ro
sunken hearth. In Chado: A Tea Master’s Almanac10, Sasaki Sanmi, a
journalist and Urasenke household intimate, says that it is a lifetime’s
greatest honor to be invited to witness the kuchi-kiri breaking of the seal of
the chatsubo and tasting the first chanoyu. The opening of chatsubo tea
container is done in the presence of guests, who admire the container and
wrappings. The chaseki tea ceremony meal is then served and eaten in silence so
that the sound of the milling wheels grinding the new tea may be heard. Only
then will the temae ritual presentation begin, first with kencha ritual
offering of thick tea to the ancestors, Buddha, etc., followed by a single bowl
of koicha shared among several guests, followed by individual bowls of usucha,
thinly prepared tea.
Much
Ado About Matcha
Concerns
(or lack thereof) by the general population about the agricultural and
manufacturing processes of tea are no different than any food these days, but,
because of the tea ceremony, there has been much ado about matcha that rivals,
and arguably, exceeds, that of the West’s obsession with wine. To that end, our
dear Matcha-sama might be considered the ultimate “guest” of a chaji formal tea
gathering, with the humans merely there to extend the welcome and adore her.
But, at the conclusion of the hours-long event, we will know very little about
her, save her name.
What’s
in a Name?
The
finest matchas, both as koicha and usucha, are given chamei tea names, often
awarded together in pairs, by a renown tea master or temple. Rather than hint
at the taste, they serve merely as marketing ploys. These identifications
function much the same as names of perfume: Channel’s #4 or #5, for example.
Without our having prior experience of comparisons, as it regards the taste,
these names don’t help any more than Shukô’s describing the taste of tea as
“Zen”. Tea students are taught the names of their affiliated school’s
preferences and are encouraged to purchase these products. The tea’s chamei,
however, will be taken into consideration when planning a tea gathering’s
poetic framework (including the sentiment of the scroll displayed in the
tokonoma, the poetic name of other utensils, etc.).
Particular
blends that bear chamei may be produced over several years and even through
several generations of tea masters, such as the following list of currently
available teas11 demonstrates:
Chamei
|
English11
|
Gonomi (Favored By)
|
Plantation
|
Matcha Grade
|
Kaichi no Mukashi
|
Resourceful Knowledge
|
Hounsai, Urasenke XV
|
Marukyu Koyamaen
|
Koicha
|
Shoka no Mukashi
|
Pine Flower
|
Zabosai, Urasenke XVI
|
Marukyu Koyamaen
|
Rei Un no Mukashi
|
Cloudy Peaks
|
Futessai, Mushanokojisenke X
|
Gion Tsujirien
|
Myofu no Mukashi
|
Mysterious Wind
|
Jimyosai, Omotesenke XIV
|
Marukyu Koyamaen
|
Iori no Tomo
|
Friends of the Hearth
|
Tantansai, Urasenke XIV
|
Gion Tsujiri
|
Usucha
|
Shiun
|
Purple Cloud
|
Tantansai, Urasenke XIV
|
Shoraien
|
Kiun
|
Happy Cloud
|
Hounsai, Urasenke XV
|
Marukyu Koyama-en
|
Seijo no Shiro
|
Pure Peace
|
Zabosai, Urasenke XVI
|
Marukyu Koyamaen
|
Michi no Shiro
|
The Path
|
Futessai, Mushanokojisenke X
|
Ryuu-ou-en
|
Shofu
|
Auspicious Breeze
|
Futessai, Mushanokojisenke X
|
Marukyu Koyama-en
|
Koungou
|
Diamond
|
Jimyosai, Omotesenke XIV
|
Gion Tsujiri
|
[Note: Tantansai, Hounsai and
Zabosai, are grandfather, father and son, Urasenke Oiemoto Sen Soshitsu XIV,
XV and XVI, respectively.]
|
Other names may reference an auspicious
occasion, specific poetic reference, etc.
Chamei
|
English
|
Special
Occasion
|
Plantation
|
Matcha Grade
|
Kento no Mukashi
|
Building Kyoto
|
Created to celebrate Kyoto's 1200th
anniversary.
|
Gion Tsujirien
|
Koicha
|
Kinjo no Mukashi
|
Above the Brocade / Maple leaves of
autumn
|
Pun on the phrase to offer something
to someone above your status level
|
Ryuu-ou-en
|
Koicha
|
Tenju
|
Godsend from Heaven
|
Exceptionally high quality
|
Marukyu Koyamaen
|
Koicha
|
Chigi no Shiro
|
A Thousand Trees
|
Reference to the trees that are
planted every 20 years for the rebuilding of Ise Jima, considered the
spiritual birth place of Japan’s islands and the country’s most revered
Shinto shrine
|
Marukyu Koyamaen
|
Usucha
|
*Toma no Shiro
|
Rustic Bamboo Sudare Screen
|
Enshuryu lineage refers to apoem
about the sunset on a beach -'as I look around there are no maple leaves, no
cherry blossoms just a sudare screen hut in the autumn sunset'
|
Ryuu-ou-en
|
Usucha
|
To make matters even more confusing, a single tea blend may be
given several names, by each of several different grand tea masters. Examples
from Ippodo are:
Hounsai, Urasenke XV
|
Jimyosai,
Omotesenke XIV
|
Seiun =
|
Wakamatsu no Mukashi
|
Ikuyo no Mukashi =
|
Kimmo no Mukashi
|
In
addition, special matchas are often created in limited “editions” and
quantities for special events, such as Ippodo’s Shin Shun Wakamatsu-no-mukashi
koicha, and Shin Shun Seiun usucha were available only from December 2007 until
mid January 2008, as long as supplies lasted.
Names
often have distinguishing terms that identify koicha from usucha. Mukashi, in
the former, refers to “tradition” or “classic,” and hints at the older root
stock, are selected to create the highest quality koicha. In the case of
usucha, the word shiro, literally “white”, is nuanced to conjure up a sense of
freshness or renewal, a characteristic value of Japanese Shinto, as in the
reference noted above to Chigi no Shiro.
Chinese poet Wang Yu-Ch'eng (王禹偁, 954-1001 from Chuyeh in the
Shandong province. eulogised tea as "flooding his soul like a direct
appeal, that its delicate bitterness reminded him of the aftertaste of a good
counsel."12
Tea
Tasting “Contests”
According
to Murai Yasuhiko13, “The occurrence of tasting “contests”, recorded as
early as the Kamakura period (1192–1333), were known as tôcha, emerged as a
result of the great expansion of tea cultivation. In contract to the Chinese
practice of judging tea by its quality, the concomitant spread of tea drinking
in this age, the tôcha of Japan were competitions aimed at distinguishing among
teas according to the regions where they were grown”, usually comparing
Toga-no-o and to others, similar to that of the popular incense contests.
As
tea culture grew increasingly more popular among the secular classes and
distanced from the internal discipline of the temples, things got wildly out of
hand with heavy wagering and extravagances, associated with entertainment,
crossing social boundaries. Shukô admonished against turning the ritual
preparation of tea into a “game” around the same time that a growing profession
of tea master was emerging, as was noted earlier. Tasting “rules” were
incorporated into cha-kabuki, more formal, conservative tea gatherings
Omotesenke’s
VII Grand Master Joshinsai Tennen, 1705-1751) and his older brother, Urasenke
VIII Oiemoto Yugensai Itto (1719-1771), adopted into the family to continue the
lineage, created “contests” for tea tasting pastimes within the context of the
Zen teachings of Daitokuji’s Priest Mugaku Soen. Still practiced today as one
of the training exercises of tea students, chakabuki is a formal exercise to
help develop one’s sensitivities to discriminate one tea from another14,
but still not to describe the taste per se.
Cha-kabuki
procedure is done in a large tea room among at least four guests, a host and a
recorder. The challenge is to distinguish the identities of three koichas in a
blind tasting after having sampled two of them with their chamei, poetic names
revealed. The third, unknown tea, is literally called kyaku, guest. While there
may have been verbal discussions afterwards as to why one taster was confident
in his/her selections, the written records simply record their guesses. there
are no hints as to indication of specific flavors that contributed to the
choice.
Yasui-san
of Hibiki-an, an Uji tea company, advises that, “There were certainly the
flavor distinctions not only vertically but horizontally on matcha a long time
ago. The vertical distinctions just depend on the quality. Today, there is
almost only vertical distinction on matcha,” as opposed to sencha and gyokuro
types. “Therefore, today, it is not easy to enjoy "matcha chakabuki".
On
Our Own
After
all this, we’re back where we started. What is the taste of matcha? How can we
distinguish the difference from one product to another? Does it really matter?
A
survey of English language matcha websites – retailers / wholesalers and
producers produce a consensus that better quality = better taste = higher
price. The higher priced matcha have a more complex, smoother, rounded flavor
and a gentle, natural sweetness, but that’s about it for descriptors.
Bitterness, the original medicinal quality associated with the health of the
heart – is completely missing. The difference in flavor among the blends of
matcha is more subtle than with steeped teas. Compared to sencha, matcha is
weak in astringency and strong “mellowness”, due to its being shaded during the
final weeks of growth.
Koicha
can be made thin with very satisfactory results, but usucha is not usually
prepared in koicha concentration as it is a bit more bitter. Tea shop owners
have suggested that a “beginner”, whether formally a student of chado or
someone who just wants to drink matcha, should try the lesser expensive grades
first, perhaps feeling that the most subtle taste notes (?) would be lost and
money wasted.
The
chakabuki section of Urasenke’s multivolume encyclopedia of temae (AKA the
“green” books -- Japanese language, only) the first taste of koicha should be
with the tip of the tongue, noticing the burst of flavor and then one must
recollect the impression it leaves in the hara, the depth of center of one’s
being, two fingers below the navel. A similar sentiment was expressed by the
late (as in deceased) “Tea Man” in his online blog15, who suggested developing
a personal set of parameters, an alphabetic collection of constant points of
reference which, when combined, create a glossary and, ultimately, new a
composition narrating an experience, “as though tea talks to one as it allows
itself to be drunk.”
Everyone
says it’s subjective, but why go to the trouble if there’s no distinction?
Flavor it is well known, is a factor of many variables not yet discussed. The
“Tea Man” website (no longer operating)15 waxes poetic about influence of “nose”, volatile
aromas, vs the nonvolatile, action in the taste bud department.
Even
without the fanfare and fuss of the kuchi-kiri, opening up a new tin of matcha,
is a sheer delight: The “whoosh” of breaking the aluminum seal bursts forth
with the sweet aroma of young mowed grass, perhaps full meadow sparkling with a
freshness of summer rain. In the winter, when the tearoom air is driest from
the heat of the ro sunken hearth and the ko incense is heavier, the tea is relatively
fresher and brighter in taste than in the summer, full of humidity and a breath
of sandalwood incense mixes with the fresh air of the open window. This is why
no perfume (or scented anything) should be worn when drinking matcha.
Matcha
is definitely the flavor of the earth’s green bounty ... but which one? The
answer remains elusive! No matter what grade of matcha one buys, the deeper /
brighter the hue, the fresher the tea. When it starts to take on a brownish
trait, it is no longer fresh. To insure that tea remains fresh, it should be
stored away from heat, light and dampness, about 59 degrees Fahrenheit. Matcha
should be stored in the freezer until it is time to open it, then taken out and
left to rest for 24 hours until any possibility of moisture will settle before
it is opened. What is open should be enjoyed within a month at the longest. The
color, flavor and aroma diminish almost immediately upon exposure to light and
oxygen.
Ingredient-grade
matcha is also being marketed by producers who export, in the hope of getting a
piece of the popular matcha colored / flavored products being sold as having
additional nutritional benefit. The forthright producers will label their
product accordingly. Because one eats the tencha leaf, there is significantly
more value than if tea is steeped. Like all foodstuffs, however, the fresher
the product and the finer the grade, the better it will be. The quality of this
lesser grade is not suited for even an usucha experience.
I
once purchased a tin of matcha from a Japanese market, sitting on the shelf
next to several types of leaf tea. (It clearly hadn’t been well stored – in the
freezer), and the price reflected a “bargain”. I used it for practicing temae,
one of the many chanoyu procedures, on a night of the full moon and ended up
doing a calligraphy of tsuki moon rather than drinking it. This is not to say
that higher grades of matcha couldn’t be used as an ingredient, but if the
taste is insignificant, there’s no point to the added expense.
Other
Variables Influence Taste
Water: If you’re going to experiment with a variety of
matchas or to enjoy one to its fullest, there are a number of variables related
to the water that can significantly impact the taste. After all, the beverage
is nothing but providing the yu hot water for the cha tea. Water temperature
determines whether you taste more of one over the other16.
Soft water (i.e. with less mineral content) is best to use for making matcha or
any tea, to reduce the influence of mineral / metallic impressions overpowering
the tea taste itself. Tea lore informs us that it is best to draw water (fresh
from a sacred well, of course, in the wee hours of the morning. There is even a
water “tasting” opportunity within some of the tea procedures. There is a
method of preparing usucha using a muzusashi freshwater container that is a
tsurube, wooden well bucket draped with shimenawa with gohei a rice straw rope
and white paper cuttings. This indicates to the guest that the host has gone to
trouble to secure special water about which she or he might inquire.
Water
Temperature: The kama iron kettle
used to heat the water – its will also impact the taste of the water and thus
the tea. Even the speed in which the water has reached its boil will make a
difference. Using sumi charcoal during the tea ritual (with its replenishment
mid-way) will have the water boiling at just the right speed and thus
temperature: emitting the sound called matsukaze “wind in the pines” at just
the right moments. Electricity, however, is consistent and creates large
bubbles and too rapid a boil. If the water is too hot, the bitterness will be
more apparent than the sweetness. Water should be brought to a boil and then
simmered for about five minutes to about 75-95 C before adding it to matcha.
Over-boiled water is depleted of oxygen and creates a “flat” taste.17
Shape
of Drinking Vessel: Taking another
lead from wine, the shape of the tea bowl may have something to do with the
experience of taste. The Riedel glass company has designed wine glasses that
are shaped to deliver a specific varietal of wine (e.g. pinot noir vs. merlot)
into one’s mouth to land at the appropriate place on the tongue where the taste
receptors are most sensitive to that particular nuance. In the winter, tea
bowls tend to be taller while in summer, wider. One reason given is that the
beverage stays warmer in the winter, but in effect, the diameter of the lip
affects the embouchure, the shape of the mouth.
Condition
of the Palate: Unlike wine, however,
matcha is not best enjoyed with food. It is served after kaiseki the special
multi-course meal created for chaji formal tea gathering. The final “course” is
a “moist sweet”. Afterwards the guests take a break, leaving the tea room. Upon
return, they are served a bowl of koicha prepared to the consistency of melted
ice cream, and, whether another break is provided or not, they enjoy a “dry”
sweet and a bowl of usucha, one per guest.
Matcha
In
these days of Green Tea Mousse Pocky, jars of iced decaffeinated matcha spiked
with lemon grass and pomegranate essence, and bobba-ed chai lattes in fat-straw
pinioned take-out cups and Tea Ceremony kits sold next to Zen Garden kits in
gift shop windows under hot spotlights ... the effort made to find fine matcha
and to take care in its preparation, will reward you with a wonderful benchmark
with which to expand your experience and make up your own mind.
Perhaps
the author of The Book of Tea, Okakura Kakuzo (aka. Tenshin), the aesthete who
is credited with bringing the deepest sentiment of chado to America at the turn
of the 20th century, said it best writing The Book of Tea: “There is a subtle charm in the taste of tea which
makes it irresistible and capable of idealisation.”12 The
fact that tea, especially matcha, like any muse, has captured the imagination
of an entire culture through time and space is reason enough to explore its
storied past and its availability in our time from any vantage. I pukku
sashiagemasu!
------------------------
Endnotes:
4 According to Guinness Book of Records, the largest
simultaneous tea party consisted of 14,718 people drinking matcha during a
single Japanese tea ceremony was arranged by the City of Nishio and the Chamber
of Commerce and Industry of Nishio on October 8, 2006. This is definitely a far
cry from the 1.5 mat tea hut of Rikyu’s fame.
8 www.aiya-america.com is the North America outpost for
the Japan-based corporation.
9 Urasenke Midorikai student Eric Dean has posted on his
blog website a great video tour of Koyamaen tea production, from the plants to
the grinding and other information: www.ericdean.org
10 For a full description of the kuchi-kiri see Sanmi,
Sasaki, Chado The Way of Tea: A Japanese Tea Master’s Almanac, Shaun McCabe and Iwasaki Satoko translators. (Tuttle,
2002, Boston). p. 551-2. In all its 742 pages, however, there is a significant
lack of any reference to how matcha actually tastes! See Kyoto Journal 54 (2003)
for a review of this otherwise remarkable book of seasons by this article’s
author.
12 Kakuzo, Okzakura (Tenshin), The Book of Tea
13“The Development of Chanoyu” in Tea in Japan, ibid
14 Urasenke International Association, translators.
Tankosha Editorial Department, eds. (Tankosha Publishing Company, Ltd., Kyoto
2007). Similar exercises were developed to develop a sensitivity of distinction
for ko incense.
15 www.teatalk.com. He passed away in 2001, but the site
is maintained by the “Tea Lady” in his memory. No longer operational
16 www.sugimotousa.com/?q=brew